Screens don't damage brains. What's on them does.
It'll take 4 minutes to read this article
It'll take 4 minutes to read this article
Unlike an increasing amount of today's world wide web, this article was carefully crafted by the diligent humans at Arbiio, not AI. Accuracy is of paramount importance to us.
A viral study claims screen time destroys white matter in children's brains. The reality is far more nuanced - and far more useful for parents.
A study from Cincinnati Children's Hospital has been doing the rounds again, with Channel 10 running content about it across social media in Australia. This coverage is not citing not a new study, it was published in JAMA Pediatrics in 2019 by Dr. John Hutton and colleagues. Iit used MRI scans on 47 preschoolers (aged 3-5) and found that higher screen use was associated with lower white matter integrity - the brain wiring that supports language, literacy, and cognitive function.
Cue the headlines: "Screens are destroying your child's brain."
Aside from an inaility to prove causation and being a sample size of 47 kids in one American city, here's the critical failure:
This is where the study falls apart for practical purposes. The researchers made no meaningful distinction between:
All of it was lumped together as "screen time," a catch-all that is unhelpful.
This is like studying "book time" without distinguishing between one child reading Possum Magic, one reading adult content, and another reading through numbers in a telephone book. The medium isn't what really matters - the content is. That is what should be considered and curated by parents, and like most else in life, be consumed in moderation - from time in the sun, through to gameplay.
When researchers do differentiate between types of screen use, the picture changes dramatically.
A 2021 study published in Frontiers in Education found that active, interactive screen use (touchscreen apps, educational games) had neutral or even positive effects on young children's phonological memory - a building block of reading. Passive screen time (watching videos) was where the negative associations appeared.
Research from Swinburne University of Technology concluded that the quality of a child's screen experience matters more than the quantity of time spent. Co-viewing with parents, interactive content, and age-appropriate material all shifted outcomes positively.
A 2023 study from Australian Catholic University found that not all screen time is harmful for children, and that context, content, and caregiver involvement are the real variables that matter.
Even a meta-analysis of Sesame Street - one of the longest-running screen-based educational programs in history - consistently shows positive learning outcomes for children who watch it. That's screen time. It's also demonstrably good for kids.
A screen is a thing that displays content. Like a page. Like a blackboard. Like a canvas.
Nobody argues that "book time" is inherently dangerous. But we all understand that what's in the book matters enormously. The same logic applies to screens - and it's time the discourse caught up.
The real questions parents should be asking aren't "How much screen time is my child getting?" but rather:
Studies like Hutton's are a useful starting point for research. But when they're stripped of context, amplified by algorithms, and used to fuel parental guilt - they become misinformation dressed in a lab coat.
Don't fall for "screens are bad" as a blanket statement. It's lazy, it's reductive, and it doesn't help you make better decisions for your family.
Focus on what's on the screen. That's what actually matters.
At Arbiio, we help families take control of their home network - including the content that flows through it. Because it was never about turning screens off. It's about making sure what's on them is worth turning on.
Roblox and PSN enable enriching experiences, yet present unique parenting challenges. Let's learn why and how you can restrict access to online games.
Read now
There is more than one compelling reason to limit access to video streaming services on your family home network. Let's explore the research.
Read now
Arbiio has become an essential tool to protect Australians from digital threats. Now learn how Arbiio prevents the use of bypass methods such as VPNs.
Read now